Why You’re Scared to Look at Your Money (and 3 Ways to Feel Safer)

by | | Manage the Emotion, Podcast | 0 comments

If you’re scared to look at your money, it’s usually money shame: a bank balance starts to feel like a verdict on who you are, so looking feels like being judged. Catherine Morgan, former financial adviser and founder of The Money Panel®, shares three ways to feel safer looking at your money: make looking smaller, stay with yourself while you look, and let the experience end.

Episode overview

In 2004, Karen Millen sold her share of the fashion business that carried her name for £35 million. Thirteen years later she was declared bankrupt in the High Court, and the next morning a national newspaper ran a headline with the word greed in it. Whether it’s £35 million, the £11,000 a woman in our community found in an account she’d avoided for months, or a single pound, the question underneath is the same: what do I make money mean about myself?

In this episode of It’s Not About the Money, part of the Money Attachment series, I share why looking at your money can feel so frightening, where that fear comes from in a culture that taught us to stay silent about money, and three ways to feel safer when you do look.

Why am I scared to look at my money?

Because looking has come to mean far more than looking. We’ve been taught that a bank balance is a verdict on how good we are and what we deserve, and then told not to talk about it. So opening a banking app, a pension statement or a letter you’ve filed away can feel like being judged. For many of us it also opens a door to everything we feel we ought to be doing with money: sort out the pension, do the budget, find that letter. No wonder it’s hard to start.

What is money shame?

Money shame is the voice that turns a number into a judgement about you: why did I spend that, I should have started earlier, I’m bad with money. Notice who that voice is aimed at. It points inwards, never at a financial system that didn’t teach us any of this, or an industry that has made money feel complicated and out of reach. I want shame to change sides. It belongs with a culture that told us our bank balance is a verdict on our worth, and then told us to keep quiet about it.

How can I feel safer looking at my money?

Here are the three ways I share in this episode:

  1. Make looking smaller. Looking and doing are two different things. You are allowed to look at your bank account, credit cards, pension or investments without fixing, moving or deciding anything.
  2. Stay with yourself while you look. Notice what happens inside you as well as what’s in the account: a feeling in your stomach, your shoulders tensing, the inner critic arriving. You don’t have to change the feeling. Slow your breathing, put your feet on the floor or a hand on your heart, and let yourself be there.
  3. Let the experience end. When you’ve looked, stop. Close the app, put the paperwork away and do something completely ordinary, like putting the kettle on or taking the dog out. Give the experience a full stop.

Why do I swing between avoiding money and trying to control it?

This is the swing we explored in episode three of the Money Attachment series. We avoid money for weeks, then we look, panic and swing straight into control: a new spreadsheet, a new budget, cancelling every subscription. It’s exhausting, so we stop looking again. Separating looking from doing interrupts that pattern, because looking no longer has to be followed by fixing.

Why doesn’t financial education stop money fear?

Because information and safety are two different things. When I moved to Jersey, the tax system was completely different from anything I’d known, and despite more than 20 years in financial services I felt genuinely fearful about getting it wrong. I made a plan and ended up saving far more than I needed to. My knowledge didn’t stop the fear, because I was in unfamiliar territory. We have more financial information than ever, through Google and now AI. What makes it usable is feeling safe enough to apply it.

What is the “I’m only looking” practice?

Try this three times. Not every day for the rest of your life, three times.

  1. Choose one piece of your finances you’ve been reluctant to look at: a bank account, credit card statements, savings rates, an old pension, or separating business and personal money.
  2. Before you start, tell yourself: I’m only looking. Full stop.
  3. Look, and change nothing. Don’t move money, don’t start fixing, don’t create a new budget.
  4. Notice the thoughts, feelings and urges that arrive. Do you want to move towards control, or away? Breathe, with a long exhale.
  5. Put it aside and do something ordinary. Across the three times, notice whether your experience of looking changes.

Look first, do later. If you’re inside The Money Circle®, you’ll find resources there to support this practice.

Chapters

00:00 What does Karen Millen’s story show us about money shame?

03:54 Why does the silence around money deepen shame?

04:48 What are three ways to feel safer with money?

08:45 Way 1: Why does making looking smaller help?

10:10 Way 2: What happens inside you when you look at your money?

11:53 Why does feeling safe matter more than financial education?

16:10 Way 3: Why let the experience end with a full stop?

18:02 How do you practise “I’m only looking”?

20:03 How do you build tolerance and trust with your money?

21:45 Where can you find support with this?

Mentioned in this episode

Resources

Discover The Body of Wealth

Take the Money StoryTypes® quiz and discover your Money StoryType

Join The Money Circle®

If this episode has stirred something up for you, you don’t have to sit with it on your own. Come and join us inside The Money Circle®. It’s completely free, we meet live on a call once a month, and you’ll find resources there to support the “I’m only looking” practice.

Join The Money Circle® for free

Free Financial Coach Taster sessions

If you work with other people’s money, as a coach, financial adviser, accountant or bookkeeper, and you’d like to bring this work into your client conversations, come and join me at one of our free Financial Coach Taster sessions. I host these every month.

Book your place at the next Taster

About Catherine Morgan

Catherine Morgan is a financial coach trainer, keynote speaker and author who works on the psychology, nervous system and somatic side of money. A former regulated financial adviser with over 20 years in financial services, she has trained financial professionals in coaching since 2018. Her podcast, It’s Not About the Money, is in the global top 0.5%. The Money Panel® runs the UK’s only financial coach certification that combines practical money expertise with psychological and somatic modalities.

Connect with me

Instagram

YouTube

LinkedIn

Remember, it’s not about the money.

Read the full transcript

Lightly edited for reading.

In 2004, Karen Millen sold her share of her fashion business, the business with her name on it, for £35 million. And 13 years later, she was standing in the High Court being declared bankrupt. A £6 million tax bill that she couldn’t pay, from a scheme her accountants had advised her into years before, and an Icelandic bank that had collapsed and taken her investments with it.

For nine years she battled this in court, fighting for the right to even use her own name. And the morning after she was declared bankrupt, one national newspaper ran a headline with the word greed in it. I listened to her story recently, and what really saddened me was how long it must have taken her to find the courage to share her experience and to say it out loud. Because that’s exactly what money shame does.

We spoke a little about this in episode two of this Money Attachment series: a woman in our community who had been avoiding one of her accounts for around four or five months. We looked at it together on a call and she discovered £11,000 in her bank account. And afterwards she said, “I thought that something was going to happen to this money, and actually nothing happened.”

Whether this is about £35 million or £11,000 or even a pound in your bank account, the question underneath is the same. What do I make money mean about myself? And what does this experience of shame say about me? As you listen to this episode today, I want you to start thinking about what this looks like for you, whether that’s the banking app you haven’t opened, the letter that came through the post that you’ve filed away somewhere, or the pension login you can’t remember and probably haven’t even tried to find.

I think that for so many of us, we go about our life and our relationship with money feeling all of these patterns of shame or guilt or judgement. And let’s face it, we currently live in an incredibly unfair financial system, which can create this feeling inside of ourselves that we are being unfairly judged. And we then layer on top of this the judgement that we place upon ourselves.

Culturally, we don’t really talk about money. It’s one of the last things we’re allowed to keep private. And so it gets tangled up with who we are: our sense of self, our self-worth and our identity. Am I competent? Am I good with money? Is it safe for me to ask for this? Is it safe for me to keep hold of this money?

I was at an event recently in London called Ring the Bell for Financial Education. There were policymakers there, there were wealth managers there, and there were really great conversations happening about how much financial education is needed right now. And the whole time I sat there thinking, where are the ordinary people in this room? Because while those conversations stay in these silos, every single person who can’t open their bank account concludes that they’re the problem. I’m not good with money. I’ve made some terrible decisions. Whatever your belief is around money.

And I think for women who feel they can’t make investment decisions, so much of this comes from a financial services industry that has made it very, very complicated, making it feel so out of reach for the ordinary investor. That’s another episode in itself. But this whole silence around how we invest and how we make better financial decisions deepens all of this shame for us. And I want shame to change sides. I don’t want it sitting with you. I want it sitting with a culture that taught us that your bank balance is a verdict on how good you are and what you deserve, and then told us not to talk about it.

That’s one of the reasons I wanted to open this episode with Karen Millen’s story, because the more of these stories that get shared, the less power this silence has over us. And so today I want to share three ways you can feel safer with money. Not three ways to make you brilliant with money or fast-track your wealth. Three ways to feel safer with money, so that when you are making money or holding money, you feel deserving of it.

If you’re new here, welcome. I’m Catherine. I’m a former financial adviser and money psychology expert, and I help people improve their relationship with money by looking at both the practical side and the emotional side. And I’ll be really honest with you, I feel very privileged to hold these conversations, because I’ve been having money conversations as a career since I was 18. I’ve spent most of my adult life looking at bank accounts, pensions, tax, financial plans and investment accounts, and I recognise the enormous privilege in that. What I’ve seen over the years is that even with all this information, we still have work to do. I still have work to do around my relationship with money.

So very often, when someone in financial education tells you to go and open your bank account and look at your numbers, it isn’t particularly helpful, because you already know to look at your numbers. The question is how you start to feel safer when you do. So let’s dive into these three suggestions.

1. Make looking smaller

The first one is looking smaller. I think one of the reasons we avoid looking at money is because we’ve made looking at money mean far too much. It’s those patterns of “I need to sort my finances out”. What does that even mean? Sort out the pension, look at the credit card, do the budget, find the letter you put somewhere six months ago. It’s no wonder we don’t get started, because doing those things is like opening a door to everything you feel you ought to be doing with money.

And I think there are two very different things here. One is the looking: the awareness, the exploring, the finding. The other is the doing. And they’re not the same thing. You are allowed to look at the numbers in your bank account without doing anything. That is okay. You are allowed to look at your credit cards without immediately creating a repayment plan or switching cards to save some interest. You are allowed to look at your pension without deciding whether it’s enough to support you for the rest of your life. These are big questions. You’re allowed to look at your investment account without buying or selling anything. You’re allowed to gather information without immediately having to do something with it.

And I think that’s really important if you’ve got an anxious avoidant relationship with money. We talked about this in episode three of this series: the swing where one moment we avoid money completely for weeks and weeks, and then we look, we panic and we swing straight into control. Right, I’m going to sort all this out. We create the new spreadsheet, we set up the budget, we cancel all the old subscriptions. I’m not spending any more money ever again. We move money around, we pay that, we pay this, and suddenly looking at money is exhausting. Even saying it is exhausting. So then we stop looking for another long period of time. It’s this away, towards, away, towards flip-flopping.

If you resonate with that pattern, the question to ask yourself is: what if we could interrupt that? What if looking at some part of your personal finances didn’t have to be followed by fixing? Today might be the day you go and explore. Go and look. Go and get financially naked, as I call it in my book. That’s it. Full stop. And that in itself can create patterns of safety: it’s safe for me to look, full stop, without it having to be followed by an action or a solution of any kind. So sit with that one for a moment and see what comes up.

2. Stay with yourself while you look

The second way to feel safer with money is to sit with yourself while you’re looking. I think this is the bit we often avoid, because we put so much attention on the actual number. What’s in the account, how much debt is there, how much is invested, how much have I spent, what’s the pension worth? But I want you to notice something else as well. What happens when you look? What happens internally? What is that sense, that feeling you experience? Maybe it’s a feeling in your stomach. Maybe it’s your shoulders tensing. Maybe you immediately start criticising yourself and that sneaky inner voice comes in. Why did I spend that? I shouldn’t have done this. I should have made this decision ten years ago. I should have started earlier. I’m bad with money. I can’t believe I’ve done this again.

Whatever that voice is, that is the voice of money shame. And notice who that voice is aimed at. We self-blame. It’s aimed inwards, at ourselves. Never at the system, never at the financial system that didn’t teach you any of this. Or maybe your brain immediately starts trying to solve everything. It’s fine, there’s always a solution, I’ll go and find out what I need to do. And we bypass the whole feeling part of our relationship with money.

This isn’t about feeling it and then getting rid of it. It’s really sitting with that feeling. You don’t even have to try and change it. You don’t have to turn the fear or the anxiety into feeling calm and safe and at peace with money straight away. It’s about feeling.

I remember when I moved to Jersey in the Channel Islands five years ago. The tax system here is completely different from anything I was used to. And for probably the first time in a long time, I felt really fearful about whether I understood what was required for me and my businesses. Do I keep my business in the UK? Do I move it to Jersey? What do I do with my personal accounts? I don’t know what the right decision is here. I remember thinking, what if I get it wrong? What if the accountant gives me the wrong advice? You hear these stories all the time.

If you’ve been listening since the start of this series, I’ve shared other examples of my own experiences. But think back to Karen Millen’s story. I’ve worked with really wealthy clients who have lived internationally, and I’ve seen people badly let down by poor advice on multi-jurisdictional tax affairs, and I’ve supported clients to work through a lot of this. So I know mistakes can happen, though they won’t necessarily be mistakes I make myself. They’ll be based on information I’m given by other professionals. And that brings up this whole conversation about trust. Do I trust myself? Do I trust other people?

So when I moved to Jersey, I thought, I’m going to plan. I’m going to make the plan. That’s what’s going to help me feel safe. And there was definitely a moment of, what if I suddenly end up with a massive tax bill I haven’t planned for? What actually happened is I ended up saving more than I needed to. Quite a lot more, which, as problems go, wasn’t a terrible one to have. I eventually had surplus money I could redirect into investments. But I remember the fear. My financial education didn’t support me in that moment. I was in unfamiliar territory, and unfamiliarity brought up fear.

And that’s why I don’t think feeling safer with money comes from knowing more, or knowing enough that you never feel frightened again. When I sat at that financial education event, I kept thinking: is it really about financial education? We’re given more information than ever before, especially with AI and Google. There are so many places to get information. What’s needed is the application of that information. And that needs you to feel safe.

One of the things that has really helped me feel safe is my embodied heart breathing practice. Those of you who’ve been following my work for some time will have heard me talk about this many times. It’s about connecting into that feeling within yourself while you are educating yourself, so that once you have the information, you can apply it from a nervous system that is regulated and feels safe. That might be noticing the emotion, noticing the feeling, slowing your breathing down with a longer exhale, feet on the floor, hand on your heart. Whatever helps you to notice: I’m here. I’m looking. I don’t need to do anything yet. And then sitting with that. So have a think about that piece for yourself.

3. Let the experience end

The third way to feel safer with money is to let the experience end. This one sounds ridiculously small. What I mean is that when you’ve looked, whether that’s at the numbers, your banking app or an area of your finances you want to bring some attention to, stop. Close the app, log off, put the paperwork away, shut the laptop, and go and do something completely ordinary. Put the kettle on, make your lunch, take the dog out, pick the kids up from school, carry on with your working day. Because I want your experience of looking at money to have that full stop, that close, that ending. You don’t need to tackle the entire world of personal finance in one evening. You don’t need to open your bank account at seven o’clock and find yourself three hours later comparing pension charges and wondering whether you’ve ruined your entire financial future. You’ve looked, something has come up, you’ve stayed with it, and then you’ve carried on with your life.

That’s what I think is so powerful about this work. When I think about the woman who opened her app and saw £11,000 there, she didn’t open that account and discover she suddenly loved looking at her money. She didn’t have to become an incredibly financially fearless woman. She looked, she noticed, and she noticed that nothing had happened. No one had taken that money away. Because that was her fear: as soon as I have money, somebody’s going to take it away. Being able to look at it, notice, close it and do something ordinary helped her feel the fear she’d been avoiding and discover she could sit alongside it. And in that, she was able to help her whole nervous system build a tolerance for things that can be safe.

Try this three times: “I’m only looking”

So here’s what I’d like you to try. Three times. Not 20, not 30, not every day for the rest of your life. Three times. Choose the piece of personal finance you’ve been reluctant to explore. That could be your bank account, your credit card statements, your savings interest rates, the old pensions you’d forgotten you had, or separating your personal finances from your business finances. Whatever it is. Before you start, remind yourself: I’m only looking. Full stop. That’s it.

Then go and do it. Open the pension statement, look at the credit cards, look at your credit score, whatever it is, and don’t change a thing. Don’t move any money, don’t start fixing, don’t create the new budget, don’t decide what your financial freedom number needs to be. Notice what happens. What thoughts arrive? What feelings come up? What is the immediate urge? Do you want to move towards control, or move away? Stay with that for a few moments. Breathe. If you’re inside The Money Circle®, we’ve got some resources in there to help you with this. Breathe, long exhale. And then put it aside. Go and put the kettle on. Do this on three separate occasions and notice whether anything changes. Not necessarily the number, but your experience of looking at the numbers.

I’m not teaching you to ignore the numbers. I’m teaching you that this is less about the amount of money and more about knowing the information, and being able to sit with it so it feels safe. There surely is going to be something that needs dealing with. There always is, for everybody, even personal finance experts. There’s always an area that needs to be addressed or reviewed or improved in some way. So this isn’t about pretending everything’s fine. It really is about increasing your capacity to see what is there. And once you see what’s there, you can decide what you want to do about it. Look first, do later. That’s the message I want to get across.

Being able to look at it without needing to control it. Being able to look at it without needing to run away from it. It’s safe for me to feel discomfort without immediately having to make the discomfort disappear. I can stay with it. It is fine. I’m not going to die. And that’s enough.

And maybe, just maybe, that is what financial security is built on: lots of very small experiences of I did that, I stayed with it, I was okay. Sometimes those first experiences are easier when you’re not doing them alone, and that’s a big part of why we created The Money Circle®, our free community. There’s a live call each month where we talk about these things together. It’s a space where we can look at both sides, the practical and the emotional, and share our lived experiences, our stories and everything in between, including the weird things we do with money that make absolutely no sense. If you’d like to come and join us, the link is the first thing you’ll see in the description underneath this video or podcast episode.

If we think back to Karen Millen’s story, she built a business from a £100 loan, went through this whole experience and told the story. You don’t need to tell your story on a podcast or in an interview. But you might start by telling it to yourself. Go and look at the area you’ve been avoiding, stay with that feeling, and then go and put the kettle on. This is how shame changes sides. One thing at a time, one look at a time. So thank you for being here with me today. Remember, it’s not about the money. And I’ll see you on the show next Monday.

Catherine Morgan

Catherine Morgan