Why Don’t Families Talk About Money?

by | | Manage the Emotion, Podcast

Families don’t talk about money because shame and a culture that calls money rude keep it hidden, explains Catherine Morgan, former financial adviser and founder of The Money Panel®. She shows how money shame and money secrecy are passed down, and shares one gentle way to start the conversation your family never had.

Episode overview

“It’s rude to ask someone what they earn.” “Not at the dinner table.” “Not in front of the children.” Perhaps you grew up hearing one of these, or perhaps nobody said anything at all, and the silence said it for them.

This is the second episode of our season, Money Psychology: Borrowed Beliefs, where each week we take one of the money sayings we grew up with and look at what it’s still doing in our lives. This week it’s “we don’t talk about money”, and the two things that keep it going: shame, and a culture that taught us money is rude to talk about. I share what I kept hidden for years while I was working as a financial adviser, and the woman with the shoebox who changed my career one afternoon.

Why don’t families talk about money?

Usually it comes down to two things tangled together. The first is shame, the feeling that if anyone really knew what was going on with our money, they’d think less of us. The second is the culture many of us grew up in, which taught us that money is rude, a bit vulgar, or something you don’t bring up in polite company. Put the two together and you get money secrecy, handed down from one generation to the next.

What is the difference between money guilt and money shame?

Guilt says, I made a mistake: I made a bad decision with my money. Shame says, I am the mistake: I’m terrible with money, I can’t be trusted with it. Guilt is about something you did, and you can do something about it. Shame goes straight for who you are, and underneath it there is usually a very old sentence, such as I’m not good enough or I’m not lovable as I am.

What is the financial shame spiral?

Research led by Joe Gladstone and colleagues, with more than 9,000 people across six studies, has suggested that shame, much more than guilt, makes us pull away from our money. We stop opening the post, stop checking the balance and put the letters in a drawer, while the fees and interest pile up and give shame even more to feed on. The same research suggested that being reminded of the kindness we’ve shown others made it easier to face our money again.

Why does shame keep us quiet about money?

The shame researcher Brené Brown describes three things that make shame grow: secrecy, silence and judgement. With money, secrecy might look like hiding a credit card statement, or leaving the shopping bags in the boot of the car until the coast is clear. Silence might look like changing the subject when somebody in your family raises how Mum and Dad will fund their care, or making their wills. Judgement is the voice full of shoulds: I should have known better, I should have saved more.

How does money shame show up?

Shame often shows up in the body first, with the shoulders rolling forward into a C shape, as if we are trying to make ourselves smaller. In our money it can look like overspending to make the feeling go away, underspending on ourselves, overgiving to everyone else, hiding and playing small. And if you have a good income or savings, it can show up as the feeling that you’re not allowed to have it without struggling.

Why is money still a taboo, especially for women?

Money silence usually protects the people who already hold the power. For a long time, financial education and advice were really only for the wealthy, so many of us grew up feeling we didn’t belong in those conversations. Research from the Money and Pensions Service found that fewer than four in ten women in the UK feel comfortable talking to friends about money, compared with half of men, and only 37 per cent of people aged 55 and over. And shame isn’t shared out equally: in the US this autumn, Pew Research found that nearly one in four people on lower incomes often felt ashamed of their finances, compared with 3 per cent of the highest earners.

How do I start a money conversation?

Here is the practice from the episode. Take it gently, a step at a time.

  1. Hold on to two things: you are not alone in this, and shame is a feeling, and feelings can change.
  2. Remember a time someone met you with real kindness when things weren’t going smoothly, and notice what happens in your body.
  3. Think of one time recently when you were kind to someone, and hold that for a moment.
  4. Say your family’s sentence to yourself, such as “we don’t talk about money”, and ask: on a scale of one to ten, how true does this feel for me now?
  5. Choose one money conversation to have this week, with a friend, a partner, your children, a parent or yourself.

If the first sentence is the hardest bit, you might borrow this one with a friend: “Can I tell you about a decision I made around money that I’ve never shared with anyone before?” Or with a partner: “What did you hear about money growing up?” The Truth Testing worksheet for this practice is free in the Rich Resources area of The Money Circle®.

For coaches and advisers: how do you talk to clients about money they have never discussed?

For many clients, you are the first person they have ever been really honest with about money, and the family silence, and often the shame that comes with it, walks into the meeting with them. More information can make that shame feel bigger. What changes these conversations is asking before we tell and listening without judgement: notice the words your client uses, hear what sits underneath them, and ask, what do you make money mean? Or earlier still, what was money like in your house growing up?

Chapters

Chapters

00:00 When silence becomes the family money lesson
03:49 The £3,000 passbook story and years of secrecy
06:16 Money guilt versus money shame
08:28 How secrecy, silence, and judgment fuel shame
12:06 How money shame shows up in the body and behavior
15:50 The shoebox of paperwork and financial exclusion
19:09 How money silence preserves power and inequality
23:47 A body-based practice for meeting shame with kindness
27:09 Small scripts for starting money conversations
30:03 Helping clients talk about money without judgment
32:40 Community support and next week’s money belief

Mentioned in this episode

Resources

Discover The Body of Wealth

Join The Money Circle®

If this episode has stirred something up for you, you don’t have to sit with it on your own. Come and join us inside The Money Circle®. It’s completely free, we meet live on a call once a month, and the Truth Testing worksheet for this episode is waiting for you in the Rich Resources area.

Join The Money Circle® for free

Free Financial Coach Taster sessions

If you work with other people’s money, as a coach, financial adviser, accountant or bookkeeper, and you’d like to bring this work into your client conversations, come and join me at one of our free monthly Financial Coach Taster sessions.

Book your place at the next Taster

About Catherine Morgan

Catherine Morgan is a financial coach trainer, keynote speaker and author who works on the psychology, nervous system and somatic side of money. A former regulated financial adviser with over 20 years in financial services, she has trained financial professionals in coaching since 2018. Her podcast, It’s Not About the Money, is in the global top 0.5%. The Money Panel® runs the UK’s only financial coach certification that combines practical money expertise with psychological and somatic modalities.

Connect with me

Instagram

YouTube

LinkedIn

Remember, it’s not about the money.

Read the full transcript

Lightly edited for reading.

We don’t talk about money. It’s rude to ask somebody what they earn. Not at the dinner table. Not in front of the kids. That’s none of your business. Did you grow up hearing any of those things?

And then there were all the things that were never said about money. The bill that sat unopened on the kitchen worktop underneath all the newspapers. That horrible brown envelope from the tax office that was hidden somewhere in the kitchen. Or the way the grown-ups immediately changed the subject as soon as you walked into the room, and nobody explained why. So we learned not to bother asking.

It’s a very British thing, isn’t it? We’d honestly rather talk about almost anything else than money. So what did you grow up with in your household? If you’re watching this on YouTube, let me know in the comments. What did you hear? I’d really love to know.

Last week we kicked off our brand new series, Money Psychology: Borrowed Beliefs, with the belief “money doesn’t grow on trees”, which I know is a really common one for a lot of people. This week is a little bit different, because very often there weren’t any words used about money at all. The silence was the message.

So why don’t families talk about money? In my experience, it usually comes down to two things, and they’re a little bit tangled up together. The first one is shame: that feeling that if anyone really knew what was going on with our money, they’d think less of us somehow. It connects deeply to our identity, and to systemic issues, things we’re going to talk about in this episode.

The second is cultural beliefs. It’s the culture we grew up in, the one that taught us that talking about money is rude, or a bit vulgar, or something you don’t do in polite company. Certainly not when the neighbours are around. Put those two things together and you get money secrecy that’s been handed down from one generation to the next.

So in this episode, we’re going to look at both of these things. I’m going to tell you about what I kept hidden for years while I was working as a financial adviser, and about something I witnessed in that role. And I’m also going to share one small, really gentle way to start talking about money, even if it’s something your family never did. Maybe you’re a parent listening to this and you don’t want to pass the same money story on to your children. We’re going to talk about how you can start to have safe conversations about money in your home.

My name is Catherine Morgan. I’m a former financial adviser and the founder of The Money Panel®. Every week in this season, we’re picking one of the money sayings you grew up with and looking at where it came from and what it tells us about our relationship with money.

Before we get going, this one may stir a few things up, because we’re talking about shame. As a trauma-informed coach, I want you to be aware of that, and that’s completely fine. I’m going to share some practices you can use to support yourself. But it might bring some stuff up. So join me, stick the kettle on, and come back when you’re ready.

So let’s talk about money shame specifically. What is money shame?

If you caught last week’s episode, you’ll remember my bank passbook story. I was about nine years old. I went to the bank with my dad, handed the passbook over to the cashier, looked down at my balance, and it had gone from £3,000 to zero. If you haven’t watched that episode, go and check it out. I’ll link it below. And the shame I felt: what have I done? What have I done with my money?

What I didn’t talk about in that episode was what I did next, which was absolutely nothing. I didn’t ask anybody what had happened to that £3,000. I didn’t tell anybody. I carried that story for over 30 years.

In the house I grew up in, money was a very grown-up thing, and it happened behind closed doors. Literally behind closed doors. When my family was going through divorce, as in many households, the financial conversations were not to be had in front of the children. Probably quite rightly in many instances, because I was very young, and money would have brought along many other difficult adult conversations that somebody of that age wouldn’t have been mature enough to understand.

Because of those experiences, money was something that was talked about behind closed doors. And all through my twenties I was working around money. I was studying to be a mortgage adviser in my early twenties, then I became a financial adviser, and I had a terrible relationship with money. My salary would come in every month and I’d have spent it in my head before it even reached my bank account. And I didn’t talk about it, because we don’t talk about money, do we? So I kept all of these money secrets really well hidden.

You can imagine: a financial adviser with £30,000 of credit card debt, and nobody knew about it except me. I was carrying a lot of money shame. What I’ve come to learn since is that what I was carrying had a name, and that name was shame. It really helped me to understand how shame is different from guilt.

Guilt says, I made a mistake. I made a bad decision with my money. Maybe I bought more things on Amazon than I needed. I made a mistake.

Shame sounds different. Shame says, I am the mistake. I’m terrible with money. I can’t be trusted with it. Can you hear the difference? Guilt is about something you did, and you can do something about it. Shame goes straight through to your core, to your identity, to who you are.

Underneath shame there’s usually a very old pattern, something like: I’m not good enough, I’m not clever enough, I’m not lovable as I am. And it changes what we actually do with our money. Research led by Joe Gladstone, with more than 9,000 people across six different studies, has suggested that shame, much more than guilt, makes us pull away from our money.

What does that look like? We stop opening the post. We stop checking our balance. We tuck the letters into a drawer. Meanwhile, problems with our finances might be building up, and that feeds the shame even more. It makes the problem bigger than it was at the start. The researchers call this a financial shame spiral.

And I want to be really clear about something here. Everybody feels shame at some point. A little bit of it is even quite healthy, because it’s part of being a human who cares about other humans. Shame isn’t your fault, and feeling it doesn’t mean anything is wrong with you. The trouble comes when we get stuck in it, because that’s when it starts making our money decisions for us.

I know from my own lived experience that we can get into this spiral. If you haven’t come across the work of Brené Brown, she’s a researcher of shame and emotion, and her book Atlas of the Heart is a wonderful read. Brené talks about three specific things that make shame grow. The first is secrecy. The second is silence. And the third is judgement. I remember reading that and thinking, well, that’s money, isn’t it? That’s the entire recipe.

Money secrecy might look like hiding your credit card statement so your partner doesn’t see it. Or leaving the shopping bags in the boot of the car until the coast is clear. These are things I have done. I did all of these things in my twenties when I was in those shame spirals. Some of you might be smiling to yourself: yes, I’ve done that several times, Catherine.

Money silence is an interesting one. It might look like changing the subject completely when somebody in your family says, we really need to talk to Mum and Dad about how they’re going to fund their care, or about making their wills. Going very quiet when someone tries to start that financial conversation. Or maybe your partner brings up money and you’re like, nope, I don’t want to talk about it. Because even the thought of talking about it means you might have to bring up those secrets. It feels easier to stay silent than to talk about it at all.

And money judgement is that little voice that gives us a hard time, isn’t it? It’s all the shoulds. I should have started investing earlier. I should have done things differently. I should have known better. I should have saved more money. I should never have signed that lease. I hear this all the time in my community. We really do should all over ourselves, don’t we?

Sometimes it’s other people’s judgement as well. It’s the raised eyebrow from a relative at Christmas: you spent all this money on gifts? Or the narky comments you get from other people. And you might notice that silence creeps in here too. We avoid the conversation with ourselves as well. No one else talks about it, so I’m not going to talk about it.

We talked about this in the Money and Attachment series, in the episode on three ways to feel safer looking at your money, because this is often what happens as a by-product of secrecy. We don’t look at our numbers. We don’t look at the statements that come through the letterbox. If you haven’t caught that episode yet, I’ll link it in the show notes too.

What I find most interesting about shame is that money shame shows up in our bodies before it shows up in our language or our thoughts. Notice what happens to your posture when you feel money shame. When I see people talk about money shame, very often their posture changes. The shoulders roll forwards. The chest drops a little. We almost curl into a C shape, as if we’re trying to make ourselves small, trying to hide. You might even feel it a little now, listening to this episode. Who’s going to hear me listening to this? Who’s going to find out?

When shame is running our relationship with money, it tends to come out in a few different ways. For me, it was overspending, to make the feelings I didn’t want to feel go away, just for a moment. We might underspend on ourselves, as if our needs don’t matter, they don’t count. We might overgive to everybody except ourselves. And very often we play small in our businesses.

You might notice it in the little micro moments too. How come I get to have this when other people are struggling? Or in things that aren’t even connected to money, like feeling greedy for having a Mars bar out of the fridge, or feeling lazy for sitting down with a cup of tea. I’m giving you permission to go and grab your cup of tea right now, by the way, in case you didn’t get the memo.

For some of us, if you’ve got a good income or some savings in the bank, you might feel you’re not allowed to have that without struggling. That’s another really big one I see. I see it in my husband, actually. It’s like it has to be a struggle for it to feel momentous in some way. That might be playing out for you too.

Children are such brilliant readers of these things. When nobody explained what was going on, we filled in the gaps ourselves. That’s what happens when we’re children: we hear things or observe things growing up, and because they aren’t explained or spoken about, we fill in the gaps. And what we fill the gaps with might not actually be true. That’s the interesting thing. So many of our beliefs around money are based on perception. They’re not actually true.

So maybe what you saw growing up was that money makes Mum and Dad argue. Or if I ask about money, somebody always gets upset. Or maybe you brought something up about money and you were blamed, and you decided that something always goes wrong with money, and it’s my fault.

So have a little think about what happened in your house when money came up. Who did the talking? Who went quiet? And what did you make that mean about money?

I’ll tell you a quick story while you’re pondering that question. When I worked at HSBC, I was working in Bedfordshire, which, for my American listeners, is a beautiful little part of England. And I met a lady who came in to see me with a giant shoebox. This memory comes back to me every time I think about shame and money secrets.

She was in her seventies. She’d not long lost her husband, so she was still grieving. She’d never talked about money with her husband, because he did everything. I remember she put this giant shoebox on my desk and lifted the lid, and out came decades of paperwork. Share certificates, some for companies that didn’t even exist anymore. Dividend letters for money she’d never seen. Statements for investments she’d never even heard of. And everything was in her husband’s name.

For that generation, that was pretty common, wasn’t it? The woman looked after the housekeeping and the man looked after everything else. She was really hesitant with every question she asked, and I could sense the awkwardness around money. I remember her saying, I feel so stupid. That is shame talking. She’d made it mean something about who she was.

We spent two wonderful hours together going through all of her paperwork and explaining it all. By the end of it, she wasn’t overwhelmed anymore. She was a woman who understood her own money for the very first time in her life.

I remember my sales manager ringing me afterwards: how many products have you sold her? And the answer was none, because she didn’t need any. What she needed was someone to sit next to her while she got her head around all of the jargon that had kept her out of her own money for her whole married life.

I remember sitting there afterwards and the penny dropped. Is this why people feel stupid about money? We work in a financial services industry that uses so much jargon, it makes people feel stupid. This is why people don’t talk about money. They’re sitting in a place of shame and judgement that’s been created by a wealthy financial services industry, and investment companies that continuously use jargon. She wasn’t stupid. Nobody had ever sat down and explained it to her.

I resigned that very afternoon from my job as a financial adviser. I had no idea where the money was going to come from. I just knew, and I trusted myself, that this wasn’t where I wanted to be.

Which brings us to the second part of this conversation: the culture we grew up in, and all of those sayings we started with. So many of us were brought up to believe that money is something you keep to yourself. You might notice that you’d happily tell a friend about your hot flushes, your relationship or your teenager’s latest drama long before you’d ever dare talk about how much you earn or what you owe.

That culture of silence has never been neutral. Keeping money hush-hush suits some people very nicely, and it’s usually the people who already hold the power.

So have a think about your own family. Who knew where the money was? Who signed the paperwork? Whose name was the house in, the pensions, the savings? Not from a place of judgement, from a place of noticing. Is this why it feels safer for the men in your life to have money, and not the women? Maybe it gives you some awareness: maybe this is why I find it difficult to out-earn my partner, because I never saw that growing up in my household.

And it goes so far beyond the kitchen table conversations. For a long, long time, financial education was really only for the wealthy. You could only get financial advice if you already had a lot of money. So many of us grew up feeling like we didn’t belong in those conversations. We didn’t belong in those rooms. And if you’ve never been invited into a conversation about money, of course it’s going to feel hard to start one.

It’s still going on now. A survey from the UK’s Money and Pensions Service in 2025 found that fewer than four in ten women in the UK feel comfortable talking to friends about money, compared with half of men. For those of us over 55, it was even lower, at 37%.

And shame isn’t shared out equally either. In the US this autumn, Pew Research found that nearly one in four people on lower incomes often felt ashamed of their finances, compared with just 3% of the highest earners. So much of the shame is built by the system, by the financial systems.

Think about what that does at work. If nobody talks about pay, how could we ever know whether we’re being paid fairly? Here in the UK, the law actually protects your right to talk to a colleague about your pay if you’re trying to find out whether there’s a difference linked to something like your sex. And yet so many of us would rather do almost anything than ask, because it feels rude, or greedy, or not quite the done thing.

It’s something men carry too. So many men grew up believing they had to be the main breadwinner, so when money gets tight, saying something about it feels impossible. Money silence and money shame cost all of us. They really do.

I also want to be really kind to the generations before us here, because the silence our great-grandparents held around money usually made sense for them. For lots of them, talking about money was vulgar, or it meant admitting things were tight. And there was a lot of cultural shaming in the generations before us. Certainly in Britain, if you didn’t have land or a title, you weren’t part of the community. You were shunned.

So money conversations have been hard for many, many generations. If you’re in your fifties or beyond and money conversations still feel hard, please know there is nothing wrong with you. You grew up in a silence that has been around for generations. And like we said last week, patterns repeat until we notice them, question them and try something different. So let’s try something different together, shall we?

We’re going to start with the body, because that’s where shame lives, and it’s where we can start to soften this feeling. First, I’d love you to hold on to two things: you’re not alone in this, and shame is a feeling, and feelings can change.

So take a moment to soften your gaze, wherever you’re listening to this episode, whether you’re watching me on a screen, out on your dog walk or driving your car. And think about a time when you made a mistake, or things weren’t going as smoothly as you wanted them to, and someone came and supported you with real kindness. Perhaps somebody who listened really well and didn’t judge you at all. It might have been a really good friend. I’m having some beautiful dog walks at the moment with a lovely girl, Sarah, who lives in my neighbourhood, and we have the most beautiful conversations and hold space to really listen to each other. Perhaps it was your best teacher at school, who was always kind. Maybe it’s a mentor, or a grandparent, or even your dog, who came and curled up next to you on the couch.

Picture that moment. Notice the care. Notice the love. And notice what happens in your body when you allow that feeling in. You might feel it as a warmth in your chest, in your heart. You might feel your shoulders start to come back a little. It’s the opposite of that C shape we talked about earlier. All we’re doing here is bringing acceptance into the body.

If you’ve never done body work before, be really curious about this. Finding the pathway for that joyful feeling to come back into the body, and allowing it in a little bit, is really, really powerful.

Here’s something really interesting from the same research I mentioned earlier. It suggested that when people were reminded of the kindness they’d shown to other people, it became easier for them to face their money again. Isn’t that interesting? So before we go on, think about one time recently when you were kind to somebody, and hold that for a moment.

Holding on to that feeling, say to yourself: we don’t talk about money. Or whatever your family’s version was. Not in front of the children. It’s rude to ask. Then ask yourself, on a scale of one to ten, how true does this feel for me now?

If you’re inside The Money Circle®, our free community, you’ll find a lovely truth testing worksheet in the Rich Resources area. There’s also a lovely audio you can listen to, to help lift away some of that shame and feel safer in your body around money. If you haven’t joined us in the community yet, the link’s in the description below, or you might see it pop up on your screen.

And I’d love you to pick one money conversation to have this week. It doesn’t have to be the big money conversation. It can be a little one. Remember, what feeds shame is secrecy, silence and judgement. Having an honest conversation does take some courage, and love and compassion for yourself, but it takes the power away from the shame. It could be a little conversation with a friend you trust, or your partner, your kids, your parents, or even with yourself.

Because the first sentence is usually the hardest bit, here are a few you’re welcome to borrow. With a friend, you might say: can I tell you about a decision I made around money that I’ve never shared with anyone before? You might feel brave enough to share that story, and feel the relief afterwards of saying it out loud.

With a partner, it might be something like: I’ve realised we’ve never really talked about how we feel about money, and I’d love you to understand a bit more about the things I heard, or didn’t hear, about money growing up. Then invite the question back: what did you hear about money growing up?

With a parent: I’d love to know what money was like for you when you were growing up. I’ve loved having this conversation with my mum many times. You might notice some generational patterns in those conversations.

With your kids: when I was your age, no one talked about money, and I’d like it to be different for us. Let’s talk about money.

And if it’s a conversation with yourself, make a cup of tea, sit down, get cosy, get your blanket and some nice cosy pyjamas, and sit with a journal. Write some words down. Write a letter to yourself about money. It’s a beautiful exercise. Notice how you feel before, during and after that conversation.

If it all comes out a bit clumsy, that’s absolutely fine. You’re learning a language no one has ever taught you, one nobody ever spoke. And if you’re sitting there thinking, I’ve already started having some of those conversations and they haven’t gone very well, take a moment to notice how far you’ve come. This work happens slowly, bit by bit, and every conversation really counts.

Now, for those of you who work with other people around money, whether you’re a coach, financial adviser, accountant or bookkeeper: something that can get lost when we’re already helping people with money is that you may be the very first person your client has ever had a conversation about money with. The shame people carry can be very present in their behaviours, or in what they’re not saying about money. You’ll hear it in the long pauses before they answer, or in vague replies about what they spend, because they don’t want to be judged or shamed.

So if clients say things like, my husband deals with that, my partner deals with that, or they change the subject, then with all of your technical training and expertise, our instinct is to fill that silence with information. But for a client who already feels they ought to know all of this, more information can often make the shame feel bigger. It really can.

What really changes those conversations is asking before we tell, and listening without judgement, because judgement is exactly what keeps shame going. I always say language is the gateway to everything. Be a bit of a Sherlock Holmes with people’s language. Notice the words your clients use, hear what’s sitting underneath them, and then ask the question I keep coming back to: what do you make money mean? Or even earlier on: what was money like in your house growing up? That one question can tell you a lot very quickly.

When you reflect their words back to them, it may be the very first time that person has ever heard their money language played back to them, and that’s what can really help to lift some of that shame away. If you’d like to practise this with your clients, come and join us at our next free financial coach taster session. I’ll pop the link in the description. We’ll teach you how to hold beautiful space to help people have these conversations around money.

And if you’re here for your own relationship with money, and today has stirred something up that you want to go deeper into and be supported with, do come and join us in The Money Circle®. We get together every month and talk about money without any judgement, without making you feel left behind.

I’d love to hear from you. What was the money conversation your family never had? Come and share it in our community space, or drop me a comment under this video.

Next Monday we’re looking at another money belief, one you might be hearing everywhere over the next few weeks, with Black Friday on its way at the end of this month. We’ll be looking at why we tend to spend more money when we’re tired, lonely or sad, how to give yourself a bit of a pause before you hit buy, and what’s influencing our decisions. I’m excited to dive into this with you.

So remember, it’s not about the money. And I’ll see you on the show next Monday.

Catherine Morgan

Catherine Morgan