
We overspend when we’re stressed because spending is one of the quickest ways the body knows to feel a little better. Catherine Morgan, former financial adviser and founder of The Money Panel®, explains why we spend more when we’re tired, lonely or sad, how Black Friday marketing works on your nervous system, and shares the heart pause, a practice that takes less than a minute, for choosing what you buy rather than the feeling choosing for you.
Episode overview
When my boys were babies, I used to scroll eBay in the middle of the night while I was feeding them, and I can’t remember how much money I spent on anything that promised to help my baby sleep a little longer. What I was really reaching for was the feeling of being less tired. And there was always a little voice saying, go on, treat yourself, you deserve it.
In this episode of Money Psychology: Borrowed Beliefs, I’m exploring that saying, where it came from, and why we spend more when we’re tired, lonely or sad. With Black Friday just around the corner, I also look at how the marketing is designed to rush us, and I share a practice that takes less than a minute, so that you get to choose what you buy, rather than the feeling choosing for you.
Why do I overspend when I’m stressed?
Usually because spending is one of the quickest ways our body knows to feel a little better. When a feeling is too much to sit with, buying something gives us instant gratification, a moment of relief, and “you deserve it” secretly gives us permission. Spending in that moment happens to be the comfort that feels earned.
Where did “treat yourself, you deserve it” come from?
Most of the borrowed beliefs in this season were handed down at home. This one was also sold to us, in adverts, in shop windows and in the sales emails in our inboxes. Many of us remember the hair colour adverts and the line “because you’re worth it”, written in the early 1970s by a young woman copywriter in New York, at a time when mostly men wrote the adverts aimed at women. She meant it as a statement that women mattered. Somewhere along the way, it also taught a whole generation of us that the way to show we’re worth something is to buy something.
Why do I spend more when I’m tired, lonely or sad?
Research has suggested that we tend to spend more when we’re tired, lonely or sad. In one study, people who first used up some of their self-control, by trying hard not to think about a white bear, went on to spend more than three times as much afterwards. In another, people who watched a sad film clip offered noticeably more money for exactly the same bottle of water, and insisted afterwards that the film hadn’t affected them at all. The body decides first, and the brain comes along afterwards with a really good reason, and “I deserve it” is a very good reason.
Why do I spend money to feel better?
For many of us who overspend, it’s about how safe we feel to hold on to money, and to hold on to the feeling we’re having in that moment. If holding on doesn’t feel safe, we find a way to let it go as quickly as possible. For some people that’s a glass of wine on a Friday night, for others it’s the biscuit tin, and for lots of us it’s the shopping basket. It’s the same pattern, and then the guilt turns up the next day, along with the delivery.
How does Black Friday marketing work on your nervous system?
Countdown clocks, “only two left”, “1,700 people are looking at this right now” and “you’ve left something in your basket” all tell us there might not be enough. When we sense scarcity, we move fast: it’s one of the body’s protection responses. Urgency takes away the pause, that gap between the feeling and the click where we’d ask, do I really want this? All of this is designed, so if you’ve ever felt swept along, it says nothing about your willpower.
Why is impulse spending harder with ADHD?
If you’re neurodivergent, the gap between wanting something and buying it can be even shorter. A UK survey found that almost half of people with ADHD said they often spend on impulse, compared with about one in eight people in the wider population. It can help to turn off notifications, take your cards off your apps, give yourself longer to decide, and make a list in your notes app of what you want before the sales begin.
How do coaches and financial professionals spot emotional spending in clients?
Bookkeepers and accountants are often the first to see the patterns, the periods where spending goes up. It’s tempting to ask for more receipts or have another budgeting conversation, but spending under stress is a response to how someone feels in that moment, so more information rarely changes it. What helps is getting curious about when it happens, asking what was going on for them at the time, and offering a safe space to talk about it.
How do I stop impulse buying?
Try the heart pause, a practice that takes less than a minute:
- Notice the pull, and the little voice saying “go on, you deserve it”.
- Step away from the basket. Put your phone face down, or leave it in another room.
- Settle your body and connect into your heart space. Breathe in for a count of four and out for a count of six, a couple of times.
- Ask yourself: what am I feeling right now?
- Then ask: what would really help me right now? It might be an early night, or a call to a friend.
And if the answer is still the jumper tomorrow, buy it with your whole heart and enjoy it, without the guilt. To go a little deeper, ask yourself on a scale of one to ten how true “go on, buy it, you deserve it” really feels, and then: what do I really deserve right now? You’ll find the Truth Testing worksheet for this inside The Money Circle®.
Chapters
00:00 Why a hard day can end with an online shopping spree
02:15 Where the “you’re worth it” money belief came from
04:39 Why tiredness and emotional exhaustion drive spending
06:47 Loneliness, sadness, and the comfort of a delivery
10:22 Catherine’s £30,000 debt and spending through fear
13:19 How Black Friday urgency cuts short reflection
16:07 Impulse spending, ADHD, and planning ahead
18:16 The heart pause: breathe, notice, and ask what you need
22:31 Resources for listeners and money professionals
25:28 Choose what you need, not just what you can buy
Mentioned in this episode
Why Don’t Families Talk About Money? (Borrowed Beliefs Ep 2)
Research: Vohs and Faber (2007), Spent resources: self-regulatory resource availability affects impulse buying; Cryder, Lerner, Gross and Dahl (2008), Misery is not miserly; YouGov (2022), survey of adults with ADHD.
Resources
Discover The Body of Wealth
Join The Money Circle®
The Money Circle® is our free community, with a live call every month and a place to talk about money without judgement. You’ll find the Truth Testing worksheet and the Safe to Hold audio waiting for you in the Rich Resources area.
Join The Money Circle® for free
Free Financial Coach Taster sessions
If you’re a coach, financial adviser, accountant or bookkeeper and you’d like to support your clients with conversations like these, come and join us at one of our monthly free Financial Coach Taster sessions.
Book your place at the next Taster
About Catherine Morgan
Catherine Morgan is a financial coach trainer, keynote speaker and author who works on the psychology, nervous system and somatic side of money. A former regulated financial adviser with over 20 years in financial services, she has trained financial professionals in coaching since 2018. Her podcast, It’s Not About the Money, is in the global top 0.5%. The Money Panel® runs the UK’s only financial coach certification that combines practical money expertise with psychological and somatic modalities.
Connect with me
Remember, it’s not about the money.
Read the full transcript
So it’s the end of a very long day. You finally sat down on the sofa. Maybe you’re like me and grab yourself a cup of tea and you’re scrolling on your phone and without even thinking about it, before you know it, there are three things in the Amazon basket and this little voice in your head that’s saying, “Go on, treat yourself, you deserve it.” Does that ring any bells? I know it does for me. So why is it that we overspend when we’re stressed? Why is it that we fall into these marketing traps that go on, you deserve it? How does this impact on our spending habits and our relationship with money? Usually, because spending is one of the quickest ways that our body knows to feel a little bit better.
You know, when a feeling is too much to sit with, buying something gives us this instant gratification, this moment of relief, and “you deserve it” secretly kind of gives us permission, doesn’t it? And curious that I’m recording this with Black Friday about 11 days away. So this felt like exactly the right time to be talking about this money belief. So in this episode, we’re going to be diving into why we spend more when we’re tired, lonely, or sad. And how Black Friday is designed to rush this in us. And I’m going to tell you what I realised my own spending was doing for me all those years ago when I was working as an adviser and what I learned about that experience. And then, towards the end of this episode, I’m going to be sharing a practice that takes less than a minute.
One that you can do on the sofa in those moments or in the queue at the till or with your thumb, you know, kind of hovering over that buy it button, so that you get to choose from a place of feeling empowered rather than feeling like it’s just on autopilot and choosing you. So my name is Catherine Morgan. I’m a former financial adviser and the founder of The Money Panel®. And in this particular season, Money Psychology: Borrowed Beliefs, we went out to you as our community and asked you what were the things that you heard about money growing up. And this one came up. And so we’re picking this one particular money saying and exploring where it came from. And most of the borrowed beliefs that we are talking about over this series have been ones that we heard growing up around the home, in magazines that we read, films that we watched, lots of many different influences. And I think this one about spending as a small reward for getting through the day, you know, we heard this a lot. We saw it in adverts in shops. We saw it in masses, in sales emails that sat in our inbox. You know, there were lots of influences for this particular belief. And when I think about this one, if like me you’re middle-aged, you might remember those hair colour adverts on the television. Who remembers those with all the glossy hair, you know, swinging across the screen and this woman looking at the camera and saying, “Because you’re worth it.” Or, you know, there were so many adverts, weren’t there, like around that time, and still are today.
And it’s interesting because that one particular line, you’re worth it, was actually written back in the early 70s by a very young woman. She was actually a copywriter based in New York. And at the time, it was mostly men writing adverts that were aimed directly at women. And she actually meant this statement as a statement that was trying to empower women, that women mattered. And I absolutely love that. I loved researching where that came from. But I think somewhere along the way, it’s also taught this whole generation of us that the way to show that we’re worth something is to buy something, you know, whether that’s the hair colour or something else. It gave us permission to treat ourselves.
And for some of us, it was probably the very first time that anyone had really told us that we were worth spending money on. And these messages around money work. They do, they really do. And research has suggested that we tend to spend more money when we are tired, lonely or feeling sad. There’s also when we’re under the influence of alcohol. I definitely remember speaking to many people in the community about those kind of 2 a.m. scrolls, you know, and they’re often related not necessarily to the alcohol itself, but because we are lonely, tired or sad. So let’s start with why does this happen? Let’s start with the tiredness because I think we can all relate to this one. I certainly can.
That feeling of it, you know, it’s 10 o’clock at night. You just crawl into bed with your phone, you’re feeling exhausted and tired, and somehow this kind of late-night scroll turns into an order for a new jumper, a face cream, something for the kitchen. We probably didn’t really need it. And I remember when this was at its peak for me. I remember doing this in the middle of the night, sometimes the wee hours of the morning when I was feeding my boys when they were babies. And I can’t remember how much money I wasted on eBay, mainly buying things that I thought would fix how tired I was feeling or help my baby to sleep longer because I was just so desperate for the feeling that product would give me, to feel less tired.
It was feeling an emotional need. And there’s also research on top of this to share with you. And in one particular study, people who had been asked to use some of their self-control first by trying really hard not to think about a white bear went on to spend more than three times as much afterwards. So by 10 o’clock at night or three in the morning with a baby in your arms after a whole day of holding it all together, it makes sense, doesn’t it? The Amazon shopping basket or the eBay shopping basket gets a bit fuller, doesn’t it? Really interesting. And then there’s the loneliness. Perhaps the children have just left home or we’re in a grieving process and it’s been hard. It’s hard to even allow ourselves to feel the sadness, the loneliness.
And the thing that brings us that little amount of joy might be someone knocking on the door with a parcel. And it’s like this moment of joy, this moment of gratitude, this moment of any emotion that is other than the one that we really want to sit with.
And I think the sadness is a really big one. And we don’t, we don’t talk about this enough. And then we just feel guilty afterwards, and we feel like we’re the only person in the world that’s ever done this. And it’s so common. It’s so, so common. And it can be simple day-to-day sadness. It can be a difficult phone call you’ve had. It can be a stressful day at work. And none of these patterns means that you’ve done something bad, that you’re bad with money.
Every single one of these experiences is where our body is literally just looking for that small amount of emotional comfort and spending in that moment just happens to be the comfort, the one that we feel we’ve earned. You know, we deserve it, we’ve had a hard day. We’ve been navigating all of this grief. We’re having a hard time right now. And particularly when it comes to this emotion of sadness, there’s another really interesting study that sits around this. And this was a study that was done in the USA and it was done by a team at Harvard and they showed people either a sad film clip or a very neutral one. And then after watching this particular film clip, they gave them the chance to buy an everyday item like a bottle of water.
And that research suggested that the people who had been made to feel sad offered noticeably more money for exactly the same bottle of water. Isn’t that so interesting? And when people in these studies were asked afterwards, the ones who’d watched the sad clip insisted that it hadn’t actually affected their spending at all. They literally had no idea. And I think that does tell us so much that the body does decide first, and the brain kind of comes along afterwards with a really good reason and rationale to justify, you know, and this kind of I deserve it is the reason that the brain hooks on to. And it was strongest when people were sad and thinking a lot about themselves. Which also makes sense because when we feel low, when we feel sad, we can feel a little less good about ourselves.
And so, buying something new can feel like topping ourselves back up again. You know, it’s like the self-worth cup has started to come down, and we’re buying this new thing to give us that instant dopamine hit, this serotonin, all the good chemicals in our brains, in our minds, and it kind of tops that emotional cup back up again. Now, if you caught last week’s episode, you might remember I told you a little story about when I was in my 20s and when my salary would arrive every single month and I’d literally spent it in my head before I’d even received it. And I eventually got to the stage, over a period of a few years, where I accumulated over £30,000 worth of spending on credit cards as a financial adviser.
If you haven’t watched that episode, I’d love you to go and catch that. And for me, I was in this very impulsive relationship with money. And it took me a really long time to understand what the spending was actually doing for me. What was it costing me? How was it supporting me? And what was it costing me? And when my youngest son, Thomas, was five weeks old, he was rushed into hospital. He was diagnosed with meningitis. And you may have heard me talk about this before. It was an extremely frightening time. And what I learned about myself after this particular lived experience was that I went straight back into overspending because that’s how I dealt with stress. That’s how I dealt with fear and that’s how I dealt with the shame.
And I would push that feeling away because the feeling was too hard. I didn’t ever want to think something bad’s going to happen. And I think so many of us do this, don’t we? The feeling comes up, whether it’s sadness, whether it’s tired, whether it’s loneliness, whether it’s guilt, whether it’s shame. And we literally reach for anything that makes it go away. For some people, that could be a glass of wine on a Friday night. For others, it could be the biscuit tin. And for lots of us, it’s the shopping basket. It’s the same pattern. It’s just that the thing that we’re doing might be slightly different. And what I’ve really come to learn is that for so many of us who have had patterns of overspending, it’s really about how safe we feel to keep hold of that money, to keep hold of the emotion that we are experiencing in that moment.
Because if holding on to the money doesn’t feel safe or holding on to the feeling doesn’t feel safe, then we will find a way to just get rid of it as quickly as possible. And so that spending cycle is literally a way to provide the body with that instant relief. But then often what happens is then another emotion comes in where the guilt turns up the next day along with the delivery. So have a little think, first of all, about what is your go-to thing that you do after you’ve had a hard day. And what feeling are you usually trying to avoid when that happens? And no judgement here at all. And I see this every single day, even in places around me. Like if I go to Waitrose on a Friday evening and all those little signs around the tills saying, like, buy now, last chance, while stocks last, all these mental marketing notes.
That’s the kind of language that puts us into a state where we’re like, ah, I deserve it, I deserve this. It’s the last chance. I deserve this. And with Black Friday coming up, you’re going to see more of this. You’re going to see the countdown clocks. You’re going to see only two left. You’re going to see 1,700 people are looking at this item right now on these purchasing apps. You’re going to see an email in your inbox that says you’ve left something in your basket. Are you sure you want to leave it there? You know, there’s only 12 hours left of the sale, then the full price will go back up again. These messages are there to try and incentivise us to make these instant decisions. And when we sense that there might not be enough of something, it drops us into scarcity.
And so we do end up making faster decisions. It’s one of the body’s protection responses. And it’s brilliant when you need to get out of the way of a bus, not quite so helpful when you’re deciding whether you need this, you know, second air fryer, for example. And the one interesting thing about urgency is it takes us away from being in the pause, being in a place of contemplation, being in a place of checking the financial plan and making a decision from a place of logic and not emotion. There’s this kind of gap between the feeling and the click when we’d normally then ask ourselves, do I actually really need this? Do I really want it? Are there other things that I would spend that money on?
If I don’t make this purchase, what would I do instead? And if we’re added on top of that, the fact that we’re tired, we’re feeling a little sad, this gap becomes bigger and bigger. And all of this is designed. There are literally whole teams of very clever people whose job is to shorten that gap between how we feel and what we buy. And what Black Friday does is it makes it even more powerful. So if you’ve ever been swept away during this period, please know it was built to do exactly this. And it’s nothing about your willpower and everything about how good the marketing teams are doing to encourage you to buy.
And I want to say something for those of you who are neurodivergent because I know lots of people in our community are. If you are neurodivergent, the gap between wanting something and buying it can actually be even shorter, and a UK survey backs this up.
This survey, which was done a few years ago, found that almost half of people with ADHD, for example, said that they often spent on impulse compared to just one in eight people in the wider population. That’s to do with how a brain is wired compared to a neurotypical brain. And it can make Black Friday feel like everything is shouting at you. Buy me, buy me, buy me, buy me. It can be really hard to turn that off. So, if that is you, please be extra gentle with yourself in that week. Maybe turn off your notifications, take your credit cards off your apps, give yourself longer to make those decisions, make a list of the things that you want in advance of the Black Friday sale. I’ve already started to do this myself actually because I love a good deal.
I love getting a good bargain. And already in my notes app on my phone, I’m just literally noting the things that are perhaps Christmas gifts that I want to buy ahead of time. Like my son wants a podcast mic, so I don’t have to keep plugging this one in and out of my computer. It’s my birthday coming up, so I’m putting ideas on there for when my mum messages me and says, what do you want for your birthday? And I can give her a couple of examples. So it is helpful to prepare and think about those things in advance. Now, I also want to finish off this episode with a super helpful suggestion for you. Let’s call this the heart pause.
So the next time that you notice that emotional pull to buy something, and you notice that from a place of this little money script that’s going on in your mind, this little voice that’s going, “Go on, you deserve it.” Notice that pull. Notice that pull.
Step away from the shopping basket, whether that’s physically in the store or from your phone. Put your phone down the other way, leave it in the other room. And take a moment to settle the body, settle and notice the emotion. Take an opportunity to connect into your heart space, and just simply breathe. So breathe in for the count of four, and then out for a little bit longer, out for the count of six.
And as you’re breathing, you can do this a couple of times. It sounds really simple, doesn’t it? And it is really simple. And as you’re taking this opportunity to just sit with your body, sit with the emotion, sit with the feeling, I want you to ask yourself, what is it that I am feeling right now? Because sometimes we don’t actually know. And just asking that question of the mind, perhaps you are, oh, I’m really tired right now. Or I’m feeling a little bit lonely or a bit flat. Equally, you might be feeling joyful. We also make purchases when we are celebrating. You know, I deserve it, I’ve just passed an exam. I got a job promotion. I deserve this.
And there’s nothing wrong with making that purchase. But if it’s one that you know is a pattern that actually I don’t really need this, then put in this heart pause and ask yourself that question. What am I actually really feeling right now? And then you can ask yourself, what would really help me right now?
And it could be, I’m actually feeling tired and I need to go and get an early night tonight. Or I’m feeling a little lonely. I’m going to go and ring my best friend. And it just gives you permission to give yourself something that you deserve that is not connected to money.
Doesn’t have to be money that becomes the soother for that emotion that you are experiencing. Okay, so have a little try of that, the heart pause. Sometimes the answer can be, go and buy the jumper. And that is okay. And if you still want it the following day, or you still want it when it arrives, buy it with your whole heart and enjoy it without the guilt, without that money belief that sits behind it that you’ve bought it because you deserve it. You’ve just bought it, full stop. Not because you deserve it, you’ve just bought it. It doesn’t have to be connected to this belief, right? You could just buy it because you want it. So you can ask yourself, you know, on a scale of one to ten, when you’re thinking about this, “go on, buy it, you deserve it”, how true does this belief really feel for you?
And then, what do I really deserve right now? Maybe it’s a rest, maybe it’s comfort, maybe it’s company or someone to talk to. You deserve all of these things. And none of them come with a cost. None of them have to cost you anything. Now, I know this can bring up a lot, these conversations. We’re talking here about worthiness, self-worth, money beliefs, it can all be tied up together. So, come and join us in The Money Circle® community, it’s our free community. There’s a lovely Truth Testing worksheet in the Rich Resources area waiting for you there. There’s also a really beautiful Safe to Hold audio that you can download. And we’ve had some wonderful messages this month posted in our community about how useful that has been to our members in there.
So all completely free, these Rich Resources for you. And so if you haven’t joined us yet, I’ll pop the link on the screen right now if you’re watching us on YouTube, or you’ll see it in the show notes if you’re listening on the podcast. And I also want to say a quick word for anyone who is a financial coach or a professional who is helping people with money. You know, if you are a financial adviser or an accountant or a coach who’s helping people with money, then you’ll be quite familiar with perhaps seeing some of these patterns. I think bookkeepers, accountants are great people to start to have these conversations with their clients. You might be seeing patterns or trends or periods where clients are spending more money and they do actually want some help with this potentially.
And so when you’re spotting these patterns, you know, it can be really tempting to think that the answer is just to go and ask for more receipts from your clients or another conversation about budgeting. But actually, spending under stress is a response to how somebody feels in that particular moment. So asking for more information is rarely going to change anything. What does really help is to get curious about when it happens. You might notice or want to ask your client what was going on at that time for them, noticing these decisions that they are making and inviting in some curiosity to whether this is something they want to share more about so that they can have a safe space to have these conversations.
You know, these are the kind of conversations that we would open up as financial coaches. And if this is something that you are interested in supporting your clients with, then you can also come and join us at our monthly Financial Coach Taster sessions. And again, I’ll pop the link on the screen. It’s themoneypanel.co.uk/taster, and I’ll put the link in the description as well. And so, the next time that you are on the sofa at the end of a long day with three things in the basket, and that little voice saying, “go on, treat yourself, you deserve it”, I’d love you just to pop your hands on your heart and ask yourself, what is this feeling I’m experiencing? What is it I really need? Because you deserve many things.
You deserve rest. You deserve comfort. You deserve kindness. You deserve people around you to hold you in that feeling. And very often, it’s the treats that are the last thing that we actually really need. So, thank you so much for being here with me. Remember, it’s not about the money. And I’ll see you on the show next Monday.
